Strengthening and Weakening Arguments

Procedure⏱ 12 minIntermediateApplies to: GRE General Test, Verbal Reasoning sectionApplies to: Critical Reasoning question type: strengthen and weaken

A step-by-step procedure for identifying the conclusion and evidence in a GRE argument and choosing the answer choice that most strengthens or weakens it.

In this guide: How to prepare for GRE Verbal Reasoning

Strengthening and weakening questions ask you to pick the answer choice that makes an argument more likely to be true (strengthen) or less likely to be true (weaken). The argument in the passage is always taken as given: you do not judge whether it is a good argument in general, you judge which choice changes how well its evidence supports its conclusion. This page gives a repeatable procedure for those questions.

Before you start
  • You can tell a conclusion (the claim being argued for) from evidence (the support offered for it). If not, review Evaluating Arguments and Logical Flaws first.

  • You have a way to take notes on scratch paper, because you will write the conclusion and evidence in your own words.

  • You know that the answer must affect the link between the evidence and the conclusion, not just be a true or interesting statement.

Question stems"Which of the following, if true, most strengthens/weakens the argument?"
TaskPick one answer choice that changes how well the evidence supports the conclusion.
Assumption to targetThe unstated link the author relies on between evidence and conclusion.
Typical time per questionAbout 1.5 to 2 minutes
Answer choicesFive; exactly one is correct.

Steps

  1. Read the passage and underline or write down the single claim the author wants you to accept. Signal words include therefore, thus, so, consequently, and clearly. If the passage has no signal word, ask: which sentence is supported by the others? That sentence is the conclusion.

    You should see

    You have one short sentence on your scratch paper that states the author's main claim.

  2. Write down the facts or observations the author gives in support of the conclusion. Keep only what is actually stated; do not add your own knowledge. These are the premises.

    You should see

    You have a short list of stated facts, separate from the conclusion.

  3. Ask what must be true for the evidence to support the conclusion. The answer is the assumption: the unstated link the author relies on. Strengthening and weakening answers almost always work by supporting or attacking this link.

    You should see

    You have one sentence of the form: The author assumes that ...

  4. Before reading the choices, decide what kind of statement would strengthen the assumption (for example, a statement that rules out an alternative explanation) and what kind would weaken it (for example, a statement that offers another cause for the same evidence). Write one line for each.

    You should see

    You have a rough prediction for both a strengthener and a weakener.

  5. Read every choice before deciding. Mark each one as strengthen, weaken, or no effect relative to the argument. Choices that are true but irrelevant, or that restate the evidence, are no effect.

    You should see

    Each choice carries a one-word label.

  6. Cross out any choice that does not change how well the evidence supports the conclusion. Common distractors: a choice that supports the conclusion directly but not through the evidence, a choice about a different group or time period, and a choice that is merely consistent with the passage.

    You should see

    You are left with the choices that actually affect the argument.

  7. If the stem says strengthens, choose the remaining choice that most supports the assumption. If it says weakens, choose the one that most attacks it. When two choices both point the right way, prefer the one that is more directly tied to the stated evidence and conclusion.

    You should see

    One choice remains and it matches the direction asked for in the stem.

    Careful

    Do not pick a choice just because it is a true statement. A true statement with no bearing on the evidence-conclusion link is wrong.

  8. For a strengthen question, ask whether the argument would be noticeably weaker if the choice were false. For a weaken question, ask whether the argument would be noticeably stronger if the choice were false. If the answer is no, the choice is not doing the work.

    You should see

    The chosen answer passes the test; the main distractor fails it.

What to check

Two choices both seem to weaken the argument.

Likely cause

One choice attacks the evidence-conclusion link; the other is only loosely related or attacks a side detail.

How to check

Ask which choice, if false, would most change your belief in the conclusion.

Fix

Choose the choice that most directly affects the assumption you wrote in step 3.

You cannot find the conclusion.

Likely cause

The passage may state evidence first and the conclusion last, or use no signal word.

How to check

Ask which sentence the other sentences are trying to support.

Fix

Write the candidate conclusion at the top of your notes and test each other sentence as support for it.

You run out of time on these questions.

Likely cause

Reading all choices in full before forming a prediction.

How to check

Check whether you wrote a prediction before looking at the choices.

Fix

Do steps 1 to 4 quickly, then read the choices with your prediction in mind.

Given

A passage with a conclusion and stated evidence, followed by a question stem asking which choice most strengthens or most weakens the argument.

To find

The single answer choice that changes how well the evidence supports the conclusion in the direction asked for.

Method

Identify conclusion, list evidence, state the assumption, predict the answer, label all five choices, eliminate choices with no effect on the link, then apply the negation test.

Answer

The choice that most directly supports (strengthen) or attacks (weaken) the assumption linking the evidence to the conclusion.

Examples

Weaken: alternative cause

Passage: A city's new bike lanes were installed last year, and bicycle accidents fell by 20 percent. Therefore the bike lanes caused the drop in accidents.

The assumption is that nothing else changed that could explain the drop. A choice saying that a strict new speed limit was enforced in the same year offers another cause and weakens the argument.

Output
<p>Correct choice: the one introducing the speed limit as an alternative explanation.</p>

Strengthen: rule out an alternative

Same passage. A choice saying that accident rates in comparable cities without new bike lanes did not fall over the same period rules out a general trend and strengthens the claim that the lanes caused the drop.

Output
<p>Correct choice: the one showing the drop was specific to the city with new lanes.</p>
Notes

Strengthen and weaken questions reward precision, not general knowledge. The correct answer is almost always a statement about the specific evidence and conclusion in the passage. If a choice requires you to bring in outside facts to see why it matters, it is probably wrong.

Watch for the words some, many, and all in the choices: a choice about some cases usually has less effect on the argument than a choice about all or most cases.

See also