Evaluating Arguments and Logical Flaws

Procedure⏱ 12 minIntermediateApplies to: GRE General Test, Verbal Reasoning

A step-by-step procedure for breaking a GRE argument into premises and conclusion, locating the logical gap, and predicting the answer before reading the choices.

In this guide: How to prepare for GRE Verbal Reasoning

Argument questions on GRE Verbal Reasoning ask you to judge how well a short passage reasons. You do not need to know formal logic notation. You need to separate what the author assumes or states from what the author concludes, and then ask whether the conclusion really follows. This page gives you a repeatable procedure for doing that under time pressure.

Before you start
  • A short argument passage (2–5 sentences) from an official GRE practice set or a GRE-style question bank.

  • A timer, so you practise at test pace: roughly 1.5–2 minutes per argument question.

  • A notebook or a plain text file to record the premise, the conclusion and the gap for each passage.

SectionGRE Verbal Reasoning
Question familyCritical Reasoning (argument evaluation)
Typical passage length2–5 sentences
Target time per question1.5–2 minutes
Core skillSeparating premises from conclusion and naming the unstated assumption

Steps

  1. Before reading the passage, read the question. It tells you what kind of judgement to make: which choice strengthens, weakens, states an assumption, or explains a result. Knowing the task stops you from evaluating the argument in the wrong direction.

    You should see

    You can say in one sentence what the question asks you to do, for example: “Find the choice that most weakens the conclusion.”

  2. The conclusion is the claim the author wants you to accept. Look for signal words such as therefore, thus, hence, so, consequently, clearly and must. If there is no signal word, ask: “Which sentence is the author trying to prove?” That sentence is the conclusion.

    You should see

    You have written the conclusion as a single sentence in your notes.

  3. Premises are the evidence the author offers: facts, statistics, studies, examples or accepted claims. Signal words include because, since, for, given that and studies show. Write each premise as a short bullet. Anything that is not a premise and not the conclusion is usually background or an aside.

    You should see

    Your notes show one conclusion and one or more premises, with no sentence left unclassified.

  4. Ask what must also be true for the premises to support the conclusion. The answer is the unstated assumption, and the gap is the space between the premises and the conclusion. Phrase it as a question beginning “Does the argument assume that …?” This makes the gap concrete and easy to match against answer choices.

    You should see

    You have one sentence of the form “The argument assumes that …”, which is the exact point the correct answer will address.

  5. Most GRE argument gaps fall into a few patterns. Naming the pattern helps you predict the answer. Common patterns:

    • Correlation treated as causation: two things happen together, so one is said to cause the other.
    • Unrepresentative sample: a small or biased group is used to describe a larger population.
    • False dilemma: only two options are presented when others exist.
    • Hasty generalisation: a broad conclusion is drawn from too few cases.
    • Confusing necessary and sufficient conditions: a requirement is treated as a guarantee.
    • Appeal to authority or popularity: a claim is accepted because an expert or many people say so.
    You should see

    You can label the gap with one of the patterns above, or describe it in your own words if it does not fit.

  6. Write a one-line prediction: for a weaken question, “The answer will show that …”; for an assumption question, “The answer will state that …”. Then read the choices and pick the one closest to your prediction. This protects you from choices that are true but irrelevant, or that attack a premise instead of the reasoning.

    You should see

    You have a written prediction and can point to the choice that matches it.

  7. Cross out any choice that (a) restates a premise, (b) is about a topic the argument never mentions, (c) is too strong or absolute, or (d) answers a different question from the one asked. The remaining choice is usually the answer.

    You should see

    One choice remains and it addresses the gap you identified in step 4.

What to check

You cannot tell which sentence is the conclusion.

Likely cause

The passage may contain several claims, or the conclusion may come first.

How to check

Ask: “Which sentence is the author trying to prove?” and look for therefore, thus or must.

Fix

Write the candidate conclusion at the top of your notes and check that every other sentence supports it. If one does not, you have chosen the wrong sentence.

Two answer choices both seem to weaken the argument.

Likely cause

One choice may attack a premise or an irrelevant detail, while the other attacks the reasoning itself.

How to check

Compare each choice with your written gap sentence from step 4.

Fix

Keep the choice that directly addresses the gap; discard the one that merely contradicts a premise or changes the subject.

You run out of time on argument questions.

Likely cause

You are reading the choices before forming a prediction.

How to check

Time yourself on one passage and note how long you spend before looking at the choices.

Fix

Force yourself to write the one-line prediction first. Aim to spend no more than about 45 seconds on steps 1–5.

Given

“The new library extended its opening hours, and visits rose by 20 percent. Clearly, longer hours are the reason more people use the library.”

To find

Identify the conclusion, the premise and the logical gap.

Method

Find the conclusion signal clearly. List the evidence. Ask what else must be true for the evidence to support the conclusion.

Answer

Conclusion: longer hours caused the rise in visits. Premise: hours were extended and visits rose by 20 percent. Gap: the argument assumes nothing else changed — for example, that no new programme, advertising campaign or nearby closure of another library drew in visitors. The flaw is treating correlation as causation.

Examples

Worked example: correlation and causation

Passage: “Students who eat breakfast score higher on tests. Therefore, schools should provide breakfast to raise scores.”

Conclusion: providing breakfast will raise scores. Premise: breakfast eaters score higher. Gap: the argument assumes that eating breakfast causes the higher scores, rather than that better-off or more organised students are simply more likely to eat breakfast. A weakening choice would point to another difference between the two groups.

Notes

Practise on official GRE materials so the question style matches the test. Keep a log of the gap type for every argument you miss; patterns repeat, and naming them speeds up recognition. For questions that ask you to strengthen or weaken, and for questions that ask what can be inferred, see the companion pages listed below.

See also